THE BREAKS OF THE GAME?
Saturday, November 17, 2007 at 04:49PM Husky fans can celebrate, the once feared Monsters of Mountlake won at home today 37-23 over Cal after 5 losses in a row to the Golden Bears who at one point this season were the #2 ranked team in the nation. More importantly is that the Huskies' head coach Tyrone Willingham did the right thing by benching #1 quarterback Jake Locker by playing back up senior Carl Bonnell. Locker is recovering from an injury to his neck from last week's OSU game. Jake wanted to play but coach Willingham said "NO" to his star looking to the future of Husky football not the present.
In contrast Oregon Duck fans now know that their Heisman Trophy candidate quarterback Dennis Dixon and head coach Mike Bellotti kept an ACL injury secret for 12 days since the ASU game when Dixon was injured. Yes, Dixon knew, his family knew, Bellotti knew, team doctors knew and if you read John Canzano's column in today's Oregonian the team knew too. So the question is why did Bellotti et al roll the dice? The answer is obvious. This was Oregon's only chance to be #1 and to end up in the BCS national championship game.
One can understand why a young man like Dennis Dixon might take this risk out of loyalty to the team. The young always think they are invincible, any parent knows that. That's where being the adult in this tragedy comes in. Bellotti's decision to play Dixon fails "the adult test" which head coaches at USC, CAL, UCLA and the UW faced and passed this season. Bellotti's Faustian choice to risk Dixon's future in the NFL or MLB seems to this blogger to be unethical. What gives a coach, a mentor or a teacher such a right?
If U of O President Dave Frohnmayer had any guts he'd fire Bellotti. But at PhilKnight University one doesn't expect such courage! Hopefully the PAC-10 or NCAA will launch an investigation into "who knew what and when" but more importantly "why" this decision was made. So Duck fans how do you feel NOW? You can't blame the hated Dawgs or Beavs for this fiasco in the Duck Pond. Is winning really that important? If it is Quack Attack fanatics have deeper problems than merely salvaging the rest of this season!
We have instant replay rules in college football. How about a similar review system for coaches?
R.A.D. |
Post a Comment | 










Reader Comments